hermes-agent/optional-skills/creative/baoyu-comic/references/analysis-framework.md

Comic Content Analysis Framework

Deep analysis framework for transforming source content into effective visual storytelling.

Purpose

Before creating a comic, thoroughly analyze the source material to:

• Identify the target audience and their needs
• Determine what value the comic will deliver
• Extract narrative potential for visual storytelling
• Plan character arcs and key moments

Analysis Dimensions

1. Core Content (Understanding "What")

Central Message

• What is the single most important idea readers should take away?
• Can you express it in one sentence?

Key Concepts

• What are the essential concepts readers must understand?
• How should these concepts be visualized?
• Which concepts need simplified explanations?

Content Structure

• How is the source material organized?
• What is the natural narrative arc?
• Where are the climax and turning points?

Evidence & Examples

• What concrete examples, data, or stories support the main ideas?
• Which examples translate well to visual panels?
• What can be shown rather than told?

2. Context & Background (Understanding "Why")

Source Origin

• Who created this content? What is their perspective?
• What was the original purpose?
• Is there bias to be aware of?

Historical/Cultural Context

• When and where does the story take place?
• What background knowledge do readers need?
• What period-specific visual elements are required?

Underlying Assumptions

• What does the source assume readers already know?
• What implicit beliefs or values are present?
• Should the comic challenge or reinforce these?

3. Audience Analysis

Primary Audience

• Who will read this comic?
• What is their existing knowledge level?
• What are their interests and motivations?

Secondary Audiences

• Who else might benefit from this comic?
• How might their needs differ?

Reader Questions

• What questions will readers have?
• What misconceptions might they bring?
• What "aha moments" can we create?

4. Value Proposition

Knowledge Value

• What will readers learn?
• What new perspectives will they gain?
• How will this change their understanding?

Emotional Value

• What emotions should readers feel?
• What connections will they make with characters?
• What will make this memorable?

Practical Value

• Can readers apply what they learn?
• What actions might this inspire?
• What conversations might it spark?

5. Narrative Potential

Story Arc Candidates

• What natural narratives exist in the content?
• Where is the conflict or tension?
• What transformations occur?

Character Potential

• Who are the key figures?
• What are their motivations and obstacles?
• How do they change throughout?

Visual Opportunities

• What scenes have strong visual potential?
• Where can abstract concepts become concrete images?
• What metaphors can be visualized?

Dramatic Moments

• What are the breakthrough/revelation moments?
• Where are the emotional peaks?
• What creates tension and release?

6. Adaptation Considerations

What to Keep

• Essential facts and ideas
• Key quotes or moments
• Core emotional beats

What to Simplify

• Complex explanations
• Dense technical details
• Lengthy descriptions

What to Expand

• Brief mentions that deserve more attention
• Implied emotions or relationships
• Visual details not in source

What to Omit

• Tangential information
• Redundant examples
• Content that doesn't serve the narrative

Output Format

Analysis results should be saved to analysis.md with:

1. YAML Front Matter: Metadata (title, topic, time_span, source_language, user_language, aspect_ratio, recommended_page_count, recommended_art, recommended_tone, recommended_layout)
2. Target Audience: Primary, secondary, tertiary audiences with their needs
3. Value Proposition: What readers will gain (knowledge, emotional, practical)
4. Core Themes: Table with theme, narrative potential, visual opportunity
5. Key Figures & Story Arcs: Character profiles with arcs, visual identity, key moments
6. Content Signals: Style and layout recommendations based on content type
7. Recommended Approaches: Narrative approaches ranked by suitability

YAML Front Matter Example

---
title: "Alan Turing: The Father of Computing"
topic: alan-turing-biography
time_span: 1912-1954
source_language: en
user_language: zh  # User-specified or detected from conversation
aspect_ratio: "3:4"
recommended_page_count: 16
recommended_art: ligne-claire  # ligne-claire|manga|realistic|ink-brush|chalk
recommended_tone: neutral      # neutral|warm|dramatic|romantic|energetic|vintage|action
recommended_layout: mixed      # standard|cinematic|dense|splash|mixed|webtoon
---

Language Fields

Field	Description
source_language	Detected language of source content
user_language	Output language for comic (user-specified option > conversation language > source_language)

Analysis Checklist

Before proceeding to storyboard:

• Can I state the core message in one sentence?
• Do I know exactly who will read this comic?
• Have I identified at least 3 ways this comic provides value?
• Are there clear protagonists with compelling arcs?
• Have I found at least 5 visually powerful moments?
• Do I understand what to keep, simplify, expand, and omit?
• Have I identified the emotional peaks and valleys?