Three Copilot inline review comments on #37664, two worth landing
in a polish pass before merge:
1. auxiliary_client.py:270 — Copilot suggested keeping the
minimax-* entries in _API_KEY_PROVIDER_AUX_MODELS_FALLBACK as
a safety net for environments where the profile-based
resolution can't import or run plugin discovery. **Declined.**
The deepseek precedent (commit 773a0faca) explicitly removed
deepseek from the same dict for the same reason — the profile
layer is the source of truth and the dict is a legacy
pre-profiles-system fallback. We do not want to fragment the
codebase by provider: either the profile layer is authoritative
or the dict is. The minimax PR picks profile (matching deepseek)
and the dict stays cleaned up. The risk Copilot raises is
real but theoretical — plugin discovery runs at import time of
the providers module, which is the first thing any modern
Hermes entrypoint imports.
2. tests/agent/test_minimax_provider.py:162 — Copilot flagged
that the test class relies on _get_aux_model_for_provider()
resolving via provider profiles but doesn't explicitly trigger
plugin discovery. **Fixed.** Added 'import model_tools # noqa:
F401' at the top of both test_minimax_aux_is_standard and
test_minimax_aux_not_highspeed. The fixtures in the parallel
test_minimax_profile.py already did this; the legacy test in
test_minimax_provider.py was order-dependent and would silently
break if anyone reorganised the test ordering. Pinned the
dependency explicitly so the test is order-independent.
3. tests/plugins/model_providers/test_minimax_profile.py:46 —
Copilot flagged that the docstring referenced a hard-coded
line number 'hermes_cli/models.py:298' that would go stale.
**Fixed.** Replaced with the symbol reference
'hermes_cli.models._PROVIDER_MODELS[\'minimax\']' which is
stable under file edits and grep-friendly. The new docstring
also reads more naturally — readers don't have to look up
'what's at line 298' to follow the reasoning.
All 221 minimax-related tests still pass.
The minimax / minimax-cn / minimax-oauth profiles still advertised
M2.7 (and M2.7-highspeed for OAuth) as their default_aux_model,
predating the M3 release (2026-06-01). The user-facing
_PROVIDER_MODELS['minimax'] catalog top entry is M3, and the
recommended config for a Token-Plan install now sets
model.default: MiniMax-M3, so the aux default was the only
remaining drift.
Updates:
* minimax default_aux_model: M2.7 -> M3
* minimax-cn default_aux_model: M2.7 -> M3
* minimax-oauth default_aux_model: M2.7-highspeed -> M2.7
(M3 is not on the OAuth / Coding Plan tier per
platform docs as of this PR; the highspeed
variant was the 2x-cost regression from #4082
that PR #6082 collapsed to plain M2.7 for
minimax / minimax-cn but missed OAuth)
* agent/auxiliary_client.py: drop the three legacy
_API_KEY_PROVIDER_AUX_MODELS_FALLBACK entries for the minimax
family. _get_aux_model_for_provider() reads from
ProviderProfile.default_aux_model first (line 250) and only
falls back to the dict when the profile has no aux model or
the profile import fails. With the profile now set, the dict
entries are dead code and a drift hazard. Mirrors the deepseek
cleanup in 773a0faca.
* tests/agent/test_minimax_provider.py: update the existing
TestMinimaxAuxModel assertions from MiniMax-M2.7 to MiniMax-M3
(the intent — 'standard, not highspeed' — is unchanged; the
pin value is).
* tests/plugins/model_providers/test_minimax_profile.py: new
file mirroring tests/plugins/model_providers/test_deepseek_profile.py.
Pins each of the three profiles' default_aux_model and
asserts _get_aux_model_for_provider() returns it. A second
class guards against the highspeed regression coming back.
Refs:
- Closes#36196 in spirit (M3 support — the catalog half of
that issue is #36212; this PR covers the profile half)
- Related: #4082 (M2.7-highspeed 2x-cost), #6082 (previous
M2.7-highspeed -> M2.7 fix that missed OAuth + the
auxiliary_client.py fallback dict)
- Pattern: 773a0faca (same profile-layer fix for deepseek)
The Kimi K2 branch added in the prior commit only emitted extra_body.thinking
and dropped reasoning_effort entirely. KimiProfile (api.moonshot.ai/v1) sends
both fields, and OpenCode Go proxies to the same Moonshot backend. Mirror that
shape on the Go path so /reasoning effort actually reaches Kimi.
- low/medium/high pass through verbatim
- xhigh/max clamp to high (Moonshot's max supported value)
- minimal / unknown effort → omit reasoning_effort, keep thinking on
- disabled / no config → unchanged
- DeepSeek branch unchanged
Closes#26924 (and supersedes #26926) in spirit.
DeepSeek was missing `default_aux_model` on its `ProviderProfile`, so
`_get_aux_model_for_provider("deepseek")` returned an empty string and
the compression / vision / session-search paths emitted
"No auxiliary LLM provider configured -- context compression will
drop middle turns without a summary."
on every DeepSeek session, even when the user had perfectly working
DeepSeek credentials.
Fix lands at the profile layer rather than the legacy
`_API_KEY_PROVIDER_AUX_MODELS_FALLBACK` dict the original PR targeted.
Every modern provider (gemini, zai, minimax, anthropic, kimi-coding,
stepfun, ollama-cloud, gmi, novita, kilocode, ai-gateway, opencode-zen)
sets `default_aux_model` on its `ProviderProfile`; the fallback dict
only exists for providers that predate the profiles system.
Tests added under `tests/plugins/model_providers/test_deepseek_profile.py`:
- `test_profile_advertises_deepseek_chat` -- pins the profile attribute
- `test_consumer_api_returns_deepseek_chat` -- pins the consumer API behavior
- `test_consumer_api_returns_non_empty` -- regression guard for the
symptom in the issue
Original diagnosis and aux-model choice from @kriscolab in PR #26926;
moved one layer up.
Co-authored-by: kriscolab <71590782+kriscolab@users.noreply.github.com>
The cherry-picked PR #15251 from @tw2818 correctly identified the
DeepSeek 400 root cause but placed the fix in the legacy fallback path
of `build_kwargs`, which DeepSeek never reaches — DeepSeek has a
registered ProviderProfile and goes through `_build_kwargs_from_profile`
instead. The legacy-path block was therefore dead code.
This commit pivots the fix to where it actually fires:
- New `DeepSeekProfile` in `plugins/model-providers/deepseek/__init__.py`
overrides `build_api_kwargs_extras` to emit DeepSeek's expected wire
format (mirrors `KimiProfile`):
{"reasoning_effort": "<low|medium|high|max>",
"extra_body": {"thinking": {"type": "enabled" | "disabled"}}}
- Model gating: only `deepseek-v4-*` and `deepseek-reasoner` emit
thinking control. `deepseek-chat` (V3) is untouched — current behavior.
- Effort mapping: low/medium/high passthrough, xhigh/max → max, unset →
omitted (DeepSeek server applies its own default).
- Revert the legacy-path additions from PR #15251 — they were dead code,
and the `_copy_reasoning_content_for_api` strip block specifically
would have nullified the existing reasoning_content padding machinery
(`_needs_deepseek_tool_reasoning` → space-pad on replay) that the
active provider already relies on for replay correctness.
- Unit tests pin the wire-shape contract and the model gating rules
(26 tests, all passing). Existing transport + provider profile suites
(321 tests) continue to pass.
- AUTHOR_MAP: map twebefy@gmail.com → tw2818 for release notes credit.
Closes#15700, #17212, #17825.
Co-authored-by: tw2818 <twebefy@gmail.com>
